Sunday, January 27, 2008

Rewarding Irresponsibility?

There is a local insurance company's slogan that is "Rewarding Responsibility." That is a pretty good principle to stand on. I think most people would agree that the fundamental purpose of government is to encourage good behavior and punish evil. Sometimes I think that we get a little confused as to what we should expect from the government and what its role should be. Should the government bail people out for making poor decisions? For example, the housing industry is struggling right now because people made some poor decisions. Is it the government's responsibility to keep people from foreclosures? I know it sounds harsh, but I don't think so. That would be rewarding bad behavior on both the part of the borrower and the lender, which in turn, punishes those who have maintained good behavior. Perhaps it could be argued that the government should have stepped in sooner to punish the bad behavior of the lenders before this happened, but now to bail them out would be inferring that what they did was not their fault.

Objective observers of the housing market predicted that it was overinflated because of the low interest rates and easy credit. However, many people chose to ignore the signs because they were hoping to make a bunch of money. The market will eventually correct itself. Yes, some banks and some people will probably lose in the process, but that is the risk they took when they decided to loan/borrow high-risk mortgages.

There are some Presidential hopefuls encouraging a bailout of the mortgage industry, but I don't think there is a enough money in the already depleted coffers to easily remedy this situation. Plus, as I said above it will only continue to encourage irresponsibility.

FYI: Listen to this interesting interview on NPR that I heard in December.

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Eno,

Your right on with your observations about the so called housing crisis. There is no crisis. There are certain people who thought they could get rich easily. Driven wild by their greed they did some very foolish things. This includes both the buyers and the lenders. They all thought that they could 'stretch the rules' and wouldn't get hurt. Now they want everyone else to bail them out so they can keep the money they never earned.

I have some basic suggestions for fixing this 'crisis'...

1. Make the borrowers eat the loss.

That should be enough to end the practices that caused the crisis. Most likely lenders will tighten up the standards all by themselves. If they can't figure it out on their own then we can add a couple of other ideas...

2. Force companies to hold the notes they originate for at least 3-5 years. By stopping the practice of originating and selling loans it will force companies to take a truthful look at the risks of the loans they are originating.

3. Make loan officers personally liable for the loans they originate. The liability should be limited, but enough to make them think really hard before originating a questionable loan.


Brian from Fargo
yes there is life in Fargo :)

Anonymous said...

I was reading this "anonymous" comment and thought to myself, "That's sounds like something my husband would say!" Haha, he did!

Briana

eno said...

That's funny Briana!